5 Stars
Eric Flint's latest work of alternate history is also his first "pure" one, the first volume in a two-book set Flint calls "the Trail of Glory". Unlike his 1632 books or the Belisarius series he wrote with David Drake, there is no time travelling or sentient crystal from the far future in The Rivers of War. Instead, this alternate history of the War of 1812 and the early-nineteenth century expansion of America begins with only one small and thoroughly plausible point of departure from real history. However, the effects of this small change quickly multiply and spread in a reasonably convincing manner, in the best alternate history tradition.
The slip from real history to alternate history occurs when young officer (and adopted Cherokee) Sam Houston slips at the Battle of Horseshoe Bend on the Tallapoosa River, turning what was in reality a near-fatal injury into a relatively minor flesh would. Instead of being incapacitated for a year, Houston is well enough to travel up the Tennessee River to Washington D.C.. He heads to the Capital on the Potomac both to receive a promotion and pursue his dream of negotiating some sort of tolerable arrangement for his adopted Cherokee nation. Convinced that the expansion of the United States onto Cherokee land cannot be stopped, Houston hopes to convince the Cherokee that their best option is a "Trojan retreat" across the Mississippi that will leave them unbroken as a nation. But in order to do that, he will need both the Federal Government's support (and money) and the trust of the Cherokee chiefs.
No sooner have Houston and his Cherokee companions arrived in Washington when they find themselves under attack by a small British raiding party. Teaming up with Sergeant Patrick "The Troll" Driscol, wounded in a battle on the Niagara River in the north, Houston helps organize a last-stand defense of the Capitol that turns him into a hero and forces the British to reconsider their battle plans for their assault on New Orleans. Houston, Driscol, and their companions hurry to the Mississippi River, where the final battle of the War of 1812 will be fought, and the fate of the American and Cherokee nations determined.
What is truly remarkable about The Rivers of War is the number of authentic historical figures Flint has managed to use as characters in his story. Although the personalities of some of the historical figures have been at least partially invented by Flint (who claims to have followed the historical record as closely as possible), there is only one entirely fictional major character, freedman teamster Henry Crowell. All the characters are believable, and much more realistic and multidimensional than is typical for alternate history books. Sergeant Driscol may become uncharacteristically eloquent when discussing class struggle, but that's nothing more than a very minor irritation.
From the Tallapoosa, Tennessee and Niagara to the Potomac and Mississippi, The Rivers of War is a great read, chock full of historical details that are very carefully researched, from all I can tell. While some might be annoyed by the wealth of detail, I'm as interested in actual history as I am in alternate history, and all the details simply helped make the story more interesting for me. I enjoyed The Rivers of War more than any other alternate history book I've read recently, and am looking forward to its sequel, the conclusion to the "Trail of Glory".
I recommend The Rivers of War wholeheartedly. For those who still aren't sure if the book is for them, I should mention that Eric Flint has once again provided extensive snippets (amounting to the whole first two-thirds of the book!) that can be read free on his "Trail of Glory" Web site. I encourage you to check it out.
(10 August 2005)
